Recent advances in computer technology have tremendously increased the use of functional data, whose graphical representation can be infinite-dimensional curves, images or shapes. This article describes four methods for visualizing functional time series using an R add-on package. These methods are demonstrated using age-specific Australian fertility data from 1921 to 2006 and monthly sea surface temperatures from January 1950 to December 2006.
Recent advances in computer technology have enabled researchers to collect and store high-dimensional data. When the high-dimensional data are repeatedly measured over a period of time, a time series of functions can be observed. Although one can display high-dimensional time series by adapting multivariate techniques, it is important to take smoothness of functions into account (Ramsay and C. J. Dalzell 1991). It is the smooth property of functions that separates functional time series from multivariate time series. Unlike longitudinal time series, functional time series mitigates the problem of missing data by an interpolation or smoothing technique, and so functional time series can be thought of as continuous.
Visualization aids the discovery of characteristics in data that might not have been apparent in mathematical models and summary statistics. Yet visualization has not yet received much attention in the literature of functional data analysis. Notable exceptions are the phase-plane plot of Ramsay and J. B. Ramsey (2002), which highlights important distributional characteristics using the first and second derivatives of functional data, and the singular value decomposition (SVD) plot of Zhang, J. S. Marron, H. Shen, and Z. Zhu (2007), which displays the changes in latent components in relation to the increases of the sample size or dimensionality. Another exception is the rainbow plot of Hyndman and H. L. Shang (2010), which can simultaneously display of functional data and identify possible outliers.
The aim of this article is to collect the R code that implements these graphical techniques. The R code of phase-plane plot is included in the fda package (Ramsay, H. Wickham, S. Graves, and G. Hooker 2011), while others are included in the rainbow package (Shang and R. J. Hyndman 2011). In addition, this article also presents the use of animation, which can easily be used with all three graphical techniques in order to visualize time-varying features of the data.
The article proceeds as follows. Visualization methods of functional time series are first reviewed. Illustrated by two data sets, the visualization methods are then demonstrated using the rainbow package. Conclusions are given in the end.
The visualization methods are demonstrated using age-specific Australian fertility rates and monthly sea surface temperatures, both included in rainbow. The details of these two data sets are described below.
Figure 1 shows annual age-specific Australian fertility rates between ages 15 and 49 observed from 1921 to 2006. These data were obtained from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (Cat No, 3105.0.65.001, Table 38). The fertility rates are defined as the number of live births at 30\(^{\text{th}}\) June each year, per 1000 of the female resident population of the same age.
Although the four graphical techniques work equally well for plotting un-smoothed multivariate data, functional data ought to be smooth in nature. Therefore, the fertility rates were smoothed using a weighted median smoothing \(B\)-spline, constrained to be concave (see He and P. Ng 1999; Hyndman and M. S. Ullah 2007 for details).
Figure 2 shows monthly sea surface temperatures (in \(^{\circ}\)C) from January 1950 to December 2006. These data were obtained from National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (http://www.cpc.noaa.gov/data/indices/sstoi.indices). These sea surface temperatures were measured by moored buoys in the “Niño region", defined as the area within the coordinate \(0-10^{\circ}\) South and \(90-80^{\circ}\) West.
The sea surface temperatures were smoothed using a smoothing spline with the smoothing parameter determined by generalized cross validation. Each curve represents smoothed sea surface temperatures in each year.
The rainbow plot is a graphical display of all the functional data, with the only additional feature being a rainbow color palette based on an ordering of the data. By default, the rainbow plot displays functional data that are naturally ordered by time. Functional data can also be ordered by halfspace location depth (Tukey 1975) and highest density regions (Hyndman 1996). The depth and density orderings lead to the developments of functional bagplot and functional HDR boxplot, described in the next subsections.
As the referees pointed out, the rainbow plot (with the default rainbow
color palette) may not be suitable for readers with color blindness. To
mitigate this problem, the plot.fds
function allows users to specify
their preferred color, such as the heat or terrain palettes. In addition
to the computer-screen based RGB colors, the plot.fds
function allows
users to utilize the perceptually-based Hue-Chroma-Luminance (HCL)
colors included in the
colorspace package
(Ihaka, P. Murrell, K. Hornik, and A. Zeileis 2011). The use of HCL colors is superior to RGB colors for
readability and color separation, and it is thus preferred (Zeileis, K. Hornik, and P. Murrell 2009).
Figure 1 presents the rainbow plot of the smoothed fertility rates in Australia between ages 15 and 49 observed from 1921 to 2006. The fertility rates from the distant past years are shown in red, while the most recent years are shown in violet. The peak of fertility rates occurred around 1961, followed by a rapid decrease during the 1980s, due to the increasing use of contraceptive pills. Then there is an increase in fertility rates at higher ages in the most recent years, which may be caused by a tendency to postpone child-bearing while pursuing careers. The rainbow plot is useful to reveal pattern changes for functional time series with a trend. It was produced by the following code:
# load the package used throughout this article
library("rainbow")
# plot.type = "function", curves are plotted by time
# the most recent curve is shown in purple
# the distant past cure is shown in red
plot(Australiasmoothfertility, plot.type = "functions",
plotlegend = TRUE)
plot(ElNinosmooth, plot.type = "functions",
plotlegend = TRUE)
For functional time series without a trend (e.g., Figure 2), the rainbow plot can still be used by constructing other order indexes, such as halfspace location depth and highest density regions. The colors of curves are then chosen in a rainbow color palette according to the ordering of depth or density.
Figures 3 and 4 present the rainbow plots of sea surface temperatures ordered by halfspace location depth and highest density regions. The colors reflect the ordering and follow the order of the rainbow. The curves closest to the center of the data set are shown in red, whereas the most outlying curves are shown in violet. The curves are plotted in the order of depth and density, so the red curves are mostly obscured, but the violet curves are clearly seen even if they overlap with the majority of the data. These rainbow plots were produced using the following code.
# plot.type="depth", curves are plotted by depth
# depth is distance between median and each curve
# median curve (black line) is the center
plot(ElNinosmooth, plot.type = "depth",
plotlegend = TRUE)
# plot.type="density", curves are plotted by density
# mode (black line) has the highest density
plot(ElNinosmooth, plot.type = "density",
plotlegend = TRUE)
Adopting from the idea of projection pursuit (Cook, A. Buja, J. Cabrera, and C. Hurley 1995), Hyndman and H. L. Shang (2010) use a robust functional principal component analysis to decompose functional data into the first two functional principal components and their principal component scores. As surrogates for functional data, the bivariate principal component scores can be ordered by Tukey’s halfspace location depth and plotted in a familiar two-dimensional graph.
Following Jones and J. A. Rice (1992) and Sood, G. M. James, and G. J. Tellis (2009), the functional bagplot is considered as a mapping of the bivariate bagplot (Rousseeuw, I. Ruts, and J. W. Tukey 1999) of the first two robust principal component scores to the functional curves. The functional bagplot displays the median curve, and the inner and outer regions. The inner region is defined as the region bounded by all curves corresponding to the points in the bivariate bag. Hence, 50% of curves are in the inner region. The outer region is similarly defined as the region bounded by all curves corresponding to the points within the bivariate fence region. The colors of bivariate outliers are matched to the same colors of functional outliers.
Figures 5 and 6 display the bivariate and functional bagplots of the sea surface temperature data.
The detected outliers in the sea surface temperature data are the years 1982-1983 and 1997-1998. The sea surface temperatures during 1982-1983 began in June 1982 with a moderate increase, then there were abnormal increases between September 1982 and June 1983 (Timmermann, J. Oberhuber, A. Bacher, M. Esch, M. Latif, and E. Roeckner 1999). The sea surface temperatures during 1997-1998 were also unusual: they became extremely warm in the latter half of 1997, and stayed high for the early part of 1998.
In Figure 5, the dark gray region shows the 50% bag, and the light gray region exhibits the customary 99% fence. These convex hulls correspond directly to the equivalent regions with similar colors and shading in the functional bagplot (in Figure 6). Points outside these regions are defined as outliers. The different colors for these outliers enable the functional outliers to be matched to the bivariate outliers. The red asterisk marks the Tukey median of the bivariate principal component scores, and the solid black curve shows the median curve. The dotted blue line in the functional bagplot gives 95% pointwise confidence intervals for the median curve. These bagplots were produced using the following code.
# plot.type = "bivariate", the bivariate principal
# component scores are displayed
# type = "bag" requests the bagplot
fboxplot(ElNinosmooth, plot.type = "bivariate",
type = "bag", ylim = c(-10, 20), xlim = c(-10, 20))
# plot.type = "functional", the bivariate pc scores
# are matched to corresponding curves
fboxplot(ElNinosmooth, plot.type = "functional",
type = "bag")
The bivariate principal component scores can also be ordered by the highest density regions. The highest density regions are the quantiles of a two-dimensional Parzen-Rosenblatt kernel density estimate, where the bandwidths are chosen by a plug-in method (Hyndman 1996). In comparison to a depth-measure approach, the density-measure approach is able to display multimodality if it is present in the data.
The functional HDR boxplot is a mapping of the bivariate HDR boxplot (Hyndman 1996) of the first two robust principal component scores to the functional curves. The functional HDR boxplot displays the modal curve (i.e., the curve with the highest density), and the inner and outer regions. The inner region is defined as the region bounded by all the curves corresponding to the points inside the 50% bivariate HDR. Thus, 50% of curves are in the inner region. The outer region is similarly defined as the region bounded by all the curves corresponding to the points within the outer bivariate HDR. The colors of bivariate outliers are matched to the same colors of functional outliers.
Figures 7 and 8 display the bivariate and functional HDR boxplots of the sea surface temperature data set. As with any outlier detection methods, the coverage probability of the outer region needs to be pre-specified. If we set the coverage probability of the outer region to be 93%, then the outliers detected would match the results obtained by the bagplot. This indicates that these outliers are not only far from the median, but also have the lowest density.
In Figure 7, the dark and light gray regions show the 50% HDR and the 93% outer HDR, respectively. These correspond directly to the equivalent regions with similar colors and shading in the functional HDR boxplot (in Figure 8). Points outside these outer regions are identified as the outliers. The use of different colors for these outliers enables the functional outliers to match with the bivariate outliers. The red dot in the bivariate HDR boxplot marks the mode of bivariate principal component scores, and it corresponds to the solid black curve in the functional HDR boxplot.
These HDR boxplots were produced using the following code.
# type = "hdr" requests the HDR boxplot
# alpha requests the coverage probability of inner
# and outer HDR regions, customarily c(0.05,0.5)
fboxplot(ElNinosmooth, plot.type = "bivariate",
type = "hdr", alpha = c(0.07,0.5),
ylim = c(-10,20), xlim = c(-10,20))
fboxplot(ElNinosmooth, plot.type = "functional",
type = "hdr", alpha = c(0.07,0.5))